5th & Taylor is one of Nashville’s premier dining establishments, located in the historic Germantown neighborhood. It is the creation of acclaimed Chef Daniel Lindley, and its concept is a refined homage to the American family meal.
Here is a detailed look at the restaurant, its history, menu, and customer feedback.
Uniqueness and History
The Concept and Atmosphere:
The restaurant’s core identity is Chef Daniel Lindley’s tribute to the classic American family meal, inspired by his childhood Sunday dinners. The menu features familiar, traditional fare executed with a refined, modern technique. The goal is to foster a sense of community among guests, returning to the simple act of sharing a meal.
Architecture and Design:
5th & Taylor opened in April 2015 and is housed within a large, historic Germantown warehouse. This space, designed by Chef Lindley, is one of its most unique features. The atmosphere is best described as rustic-industrial, elevated, and intimate, with high ceilings, dark custom furniture, and low lighting, which creates a cozy and romantic ambiance.
A Tribute to Nashville:
Dominating the main dining room is a life-size sculpture of General Francis Nash, the Revolutionary War hero for whom Nashville is named. This striking piece of art anchors the space, along with an open kitchen featuring an 8-foot wood-burning grill and an enclosed patio space complete with a diamond-shaped, infinity-edged fountain.
Highlight Menu Items
The menu is categorized as refined American fare, with many dishes served family-style to encourage sharing, true to its theme.
| Category | Recommended Dishes | Notes from Reviews & Menu |
| Starters & Sides | Sausage-Cheddar Biscuits | Often described as a “MUST HAVE” item that is constantly craved. |
| Brussels Sprouts | Highly recommended by customers. | |
| Entrees | Beef Cheek Stew | Consistently called “incredible” and highly flavorful. |
| Short Rib & Wagyu Steak | Praised for being “tender and flavorful.” | |
| Beer Can Chicken | A notable, classic dish that benefits from the wood-burning grill. | |
| Duck Wings | Described as “incredible” by one reviewer. | |
| Dessert & Drinks | Chocolate Mousse | Called “incredible.” |
| Cucumber Gimlet | A unique and refreshing cocktail, noted as one of the best in town. |
Note: Most entrees are famously served with a side of incredibly creamy mashed potatoes served family-style.
Customer Feedback (Rating: 4.6 Stars)
Customer feedback consistently praises the food quality, service, and atmosphere:
- Food Quality: Reviewers call the cuisine an “refreshing, unique and elevated take on Southern/New American food.” The ribeye was called an “out of body experience” and a “melt-in-your-mouth, perfectly cooked master class.”
- Atmosphere: The vibe is described as “romantic,” “cozy,” and “upscale,” making it a perfect spot for special occasions. The candlelight and rustic decor contribute to an “inviting ambiance.”
- Service: Service is frequently highlighted as “consistently incredible” and “attentive,” with staff contributing to an “exceptional” overall dining experience.
Significant Events & Private Dining
While the restaurant’s opening in 2015 was a significant event for the Nashville dining scene (and it has received a James Beard Award nomination), no major historical events have taken place there. However, the venue is popular for hosting significant private events due to its unique layout and large capacity:
- The Gallery: A private space accommodating up to 60 guests for a variety of functions, from seated dinners to cocktail parties.
- The Back Corner: A premiere mid-sized event space that can accommodate up to 120 guests for a seated dinner or 160 for a cocktail-style event.
- Full Buyouts: The entire venue can be reserved for large events, which includes the main dining room, patio, and private areas.
Contact and Location Information
Address:
1411 5th Ave N, Nashville, TN 37208
Contact:
- Phone: +1 615-242-4747
- Website: http://www.5thandtaylor.com/
- Map: 5th & Taylor on Google Maps
